"I'm a Good Girl, I Am"
Season 5, Episode 24
Air date March 17th, 2015
Written by Oliver Goldstick and Maya Goldsmith
Directed by Oliver Goldstick
Episode Guide
The Melody Lingers On
Welcome to the Dollhouse

I'm a Good Girl, I Am is the twenty-fourth episode of Season Five. It aired on March 17th, 2015.


Alison’s trial is coming to a close, and the outcome looks even more bleak when the prosecution calls a surprise witness that not only paints Alison in a bad light but also the PLLs and Mike. Desperate to find any evidence or witness to save their friends, Aria, Emily and Spencer race to find someone or something that can prove Ali’s innocence and put an end to this nightmare.

Meanwhile, Mike becomes a target of “A” when it looks like he might be called to testify, and Ezra and Caleb have differing opinions on what he should do.


Aria tries to keep Mike away from the jury, so she turns to Ezra for help. Ezra takes Mike to his cabin but Caleb is already there waiting for them and tries to take Mike back to Rosewood to testify in court. However 'A' manages to trick them, and attacks all of them in the woods. Spencer and Emily find someone who can help Alison, but Alison's lawyer refuses to put her on the stand as she was 'high' the day she heard Alison in the park. Lesli is called as a surprise witness, and testifies in court against Alison. She produces a letter that Mona wrote before she was killed saying that Alison was threatening her, but Lesli did not take the letter seriously. Andrew also tells Aria that he went to scouts camp, and said "I never knew after all these years it would come in handy". Toby and Spencer reconnect, when Toby states that if Tanner doesn't like the fact he's with Spencer, then she can kick him off the force. In the final verdict the judge declares Alison guilty and Tanner arrests the Liars as accessories.


Cast Edit

Main cast

Troian Bellisario as Spencer Hastings

Ashley Benson as Hanna Marin

Sasha Piters as Ali

Tyler Blackburn as Caleb

Laura Leigh as Ashley

Karen Lucille as Aria

Ian Hardinge as Ezra

Shannon Mitchell as Em

guest cast

Holly Marie as Ella Rose

Keegan Allen as Tobie Cavanaugh

Cody Christian as Mike

Roma Maffia as Tanner

Brandon Jones as Andrew Campbell


Lauren Tom as Rebecca Marcus

Elizabeth McLaughlin as Lesli Stone

Christopher Grove as Douglas Sirk

Sara Shepard as Sara News Reporter

Kim Estes as Judge Robson

Livia Treviño as The Forewoman

Jay Jackson as Bill Klaka News Anchor

Kanya Iwana as Kendra

Austin Lyon as Matt

Cassandra Relynn as Guard (Im a good girl, I am)

Mazza Gavin as Leisi Gomez

Theresa Smith as Mariah Sirk

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.